[Estimated reading time: 17 minutes]
The storyteller frowned. "What do you mean?"
"Then what happened?" The girl asked again with no change at all in her enthusiasm, as though simply repeating the question would clarify the matter.
The storyteller looked bemused across the gathered children while nearby adults chuckled and shook their heads, and those further out continued their merry dance to the tavern's music, oblivious to the scrutiny happening by the fireplace.
He ended up shaking his own head and helplessly repeating his own question. "What do you mean?"
"What happened then?" Another child asked. "Did he go home? Get married? Or was he already married?"
"Was his wife beautiful?" A girl asked, one of the youngest, climbing up onto a table behind the old man. "Did she make him go to work after he did all the heroic stuff or did he get given lots and lots of gold from the king?"
"Is being a hero a job?" A boy asked.
"Heroism," the storyteller cried over the continuing onslaught of questions, more than a little exasperated and twitchingly aware of the young girl behind him, "is its own reward...little one."
"So that means being a hero makes you rich?"
"No, no, my dear, it means that good deeds make you rich in spirit."
"So," the little girl was lying upside down on the table now, "his ghost was rich? What about when he was alive though? Or did he die?!"
"Eventually, y-yes, he di--"
"What about Frederick of Morne or the Emerald Skyhawk? Did they die from being heroes and have rich ghosts?"
A wasting sigh heaved from the storyteller, and the adults that had been enjoying the poor man's suffering began shouting support towards him. But it was a young guardsman that finally saved the night.
"Come on you lot," he called, rising from his seat and waving for the girl to climb down off the table, tossing a wink to the old man as he went, "it's after hours and you've exhausted this poor fellow. Head on home. We'll have to pay him double now to compensate him for your trouble. And you two," he squeezed the shoulders of the two oldest as they gathered themselves beneath a cloud of complaints but followed obediently to the door, "you're both on thin ice with your masters as it is."
"We just want to know what happened to the hero after his story," the youngest complained again, even as she skipped off ahead of him.
"And there's plenty of time to find out, but not tonight. Go on, get!"
The children were herded out through the door to the cold, fireless night, and as it swung closed behind them, the warmest corner of the tavern breathed a sigh of relief. None so heavy as the storyteller, and he wondered, with that breath, if he had made the right career choice. Perhaps he should have found a new field to tend when the last went up in flames...
An old woman began chuckling next to him. He glanced her way. "You might want to devise some answers for the next time this happens," she smiled. "Children are insightful and curious. They ask the questions adults would rather avoid."
"Yes," he sighed again, "you're right of course, ma'am. I'll make it a priority. They won't catch me out again."
"I'm sure they won't. For the moment though, you look far too exhausted."
"It's the weather, ma'am. The chill is in my bones."
"Then to bed with a hot sack of oats, perhaps? That, I'm afraid, is all that will help you, because no matter how long you eye the barmaid," she cocked a grey eyebrow as he looked guiltily back at her, "she has neither the time nor the obligation. A sack of oats is easier."
He rose to his feet, nodding his agreement, took a deep breath--
"And," she added sharply, "stop sighing so much. You'll blow the fire out with any more of that."
--He breathed back out in a laugh instead, bowed slightly, and walked away to the tavern keep to make his request, leaving the older patrons to listen to the calm crackle of the surviving fire in his place. The silence was comfortable for a while - at least, she had felt it was - but something in the air had disturbed a few of the others.
Cautiously, one man lowered his voice and spoke. "What do you think did happen to them?" He asked, looking across his friends. "The heroes I mean, when their job was done?"
"Oh," the old woman shook her head, reaching then for her tankard. "I don't suspect anything good, do you? Not in the end. No, heroes are just men after all, and most die like the rest of us." She gestured to the fire, though didn't look up from the table. "Bright flames burn the fastest. They either get snuffed out, or snuff themselves out."
"Yeah, but...they're heroes..."
She shrugged, a bewildered frown slowly creeping across her face. "So? Their stories aren't letters of immunity, you know, least of all to Death and Misfortune. If anything, they are invitations. You surely can't believe otherwise..."
"N-no, ma'am," another spoke up, "with all due respect, I believe you might be misunderstanding us. We don't mean heroes in stories, we mean real her--"
"Yes," she leaned forwards and lowered her voice, her stare rising from the tabletop to look openly across the numerous eyes that had turned her way, "and I'm speaking of real heroes. These 'heroes in stories' - first, well, I ask you: where did the story come from? From the hero's actions, of course! There is no story without the hero. Heroism, victory, or even defeat with morals left in tact - all of these things require a hero first, and they are told on. And secondly, why are they told on?"
"To inspire?" Someone offered.
"For history?" Another spoke up.
"Lessons." Said a third, a younger guard that had been sitting with the children's escort. His eyes were hard. Purposeful.
The old woman looked at him a fraction longer than the rest, and smiled. "Yes. Lessons. But," she raised a finger, "even beneath the obvious lessons told within the distraction of heroes are others that go untold, ones of equal or perhaps even greater importance. Those of the Person beyond the People, of the unfortunate soul who tasted that fame - willingly or not.
"But!" She raised her tankard and sat back, noticing the frown that passed across the guard's brow at her words, "these are not the stories anyone really wishes to hear. And answers the questions that we don't really want to ask. And yet...here we are, asking them..."
All gathered glanced warily to their neighbours. A weight had settled in the room, though the gleeful music, dancers and drinkers a short distance away from their circle seemed somehow oblivious to it. But to those involved, it was demanding, demanding of many things, but of two above all: to be stared directly into, and avoided at all costs.
For a long while, no one spoke. No one could choose which demand to answer. But the old woman soon spoke again anyway, and no one tried to silence her.
"How many heroes," she began offhandedly, addressing the low level of ale in her tankard rather than anyone else, "do you think, live on past their moment and still manage to die a heroic, meaningful death? And how many, do you think, go on to live humbly, content and accepting of the fact that their role has been fulfilled?" She looked up. No one answered. The number of listeners had grown from nine to twelve. "And how many, do you think, are honestly beyond the rigours and weaknesses of the rest of us?" She took a mouthful as she waited, then set the tankard down. "I'm asking."
"...None." One man answered cautiously, at which the weight in the air grew somehow darker and even more dismal. "It's none, isn't it?"
The old woman nodded slowly. "The actions of heroes are intense, are they not? And what healthy mind would stare death in the face to save others? A valiant one, yes, and so few of us possess that. But what's beneath that valiance? It's a strain of madness, for sure, and it manifests afterwards in vicious ways. Ways unbefitting of how we deem a hero to behave.
"Many can't help but chase the high when it's over. Others grow embittered by the loss of the fame they had earned, or more nobly angered by the necessity of what they had to do and what they became in doing it. Some grow deluded. And the unlucky few, well...they turn mad, haunted in life by the spirits of those they were unable to save, and in death by those who died as collateral to the hubris of their actions. Actions that shouldn't have been necessary. And that's to say nothing of the would-be heroes that died before they could address the matters first. They're the lucky ones, really...
"But," she sipped again, then gestured to the barmaid for another, "I digress. Heroism is a young man's game. Swords and armour are heavy, and the stress of sneaking beneath a sorcerer's notice to unravel his plans is crippling. So what happens to those soft, malleable minds and strong bodies? Hmm? Ageing and infirmity is rarely met gracefully by the best of us, after all.
"A hero complex is, at its core, a sickness. And what happens when they do what they cannot for others purely - whether they know it or not - to feed it? To stay needed, to stay relevant, their whole sense of identity and worth hingeing so delicately on their heroism? They run themselves to the ground. They make mistakes. Become hysterical, obsessive, until they inevitably drive themselves to a struggling death at their own hands and bring others down with them in their decaying attempts to continue to help. Because, rather than let them turn to others who could help more effectively with various skills, the hero jumps in first. It's like he tries to take that barmaid's tray, the mop over there, light these candles and turn the straw on the floor all by himself in a single moment because he can't admit that others could be better suited for a particular task, and has decided that, if he doesn't do it all himself, it won't get done and people, somehow, will suffer for it.
"And that's just one example. Say the hero complex doesn't take, and they can accept the loss of their fame. What would most likely move in next? Hmm?" She looked across them all, then settled on the farrier. "Farley. Say all the horses in the world were going to be culled, and the only way to prevent it was to kill five horses in every village, but you had to do it yourself. You could get help, but you want to make sure it's done right, that they don't suffer, and that it's done quickly. So, you don't ask for help, you do it alone, then, matter taken care of, the majority of horses live on, never to be culled. You saved an entire species, single-handedly." She cocked her head. "And then, when that fact has settled and the silver on the imaginary reward has dulled and tarnished...what will stay with you? The memory of the glory? Or the memories of those many, many horses dying at your hands?"
The farrier's hands were already balled into white fists. "I see your point."
"Say it out loud, for everyone," she replied, softly. "It's important."
"The horses. The blood. Those are the memories that would stay with me."
She nodded, and offered him an apologetic smile. The man's fondness for his horses and trade was well-known. "A hero loves his people just as much. So what does anger at one's self or at the very nature of the world do to someone when they are left with time to think after the fact? It erodes both the mind and the ability to feel joy, if they can even remember what that feels like, until they turn upon themselves or upon the very people they had once fought to save. And gods forbid that the cost they paid to achieve their goal was the life of someone they loved. There is no saving the heart of someone who believes themselves the murderer of it.
"Now," she smiled and thanked the barmaid as she set down a fresh tankard in front of her, and noted both with sympathy and mild amusement the disquiet in her face as she entered and left their moody bubble, "this is by no means to say that heroes are destined to become villains, or to die miserably - though they are certainly mentally afflicted, to a degree. But it is to say that even heroes are subject to our weaknesses, and that the ones we so idolise have paid for their names in ways unimaginable. And those are lessons that, I think at least, are worth telling. They should be respected beyond solely their heroism." She sipped from her tankard. "This isn't ale."
The men looked at each other. They numbered thirteen now.
"Did...did that happen to Frederick of Morne?" One asked carefully, as though his heart didn't truly want to know, but his soul needed the closure. "Did he go mad? Did he hate the world?"
She swallowed the third mouthful of mead, spread her hands and sat back. "I couldn't tell you, honestly. Another thing about heroes is that, after their glory, many of them have a habit of disappearing from the public eye."
"Hang on..." the second guard piped up, the chair beside him still empty. Law dictated that he should have left with his partner, but instead he'd stayed to listen to her, the intensity in his eyes now even more piercing and his previously proud bearing now insulted. Personally, it seemed. "That means that everything you just said could so easily be untrue... If most of them vanish, how could anyone truly know how they turned out?"
And there it was. She watched suspicion enter the eyes of half of her audience, and relief enter the rest. Plausible deniability.
She kept her sigh to herself. "You can decide that for yourselves," she replied coolly instead, "if that makes it easier for you. This isn't something people generally want to be aware of, so I wouldn't blame you. Though," she added offhandedly, "their spirits might."
"And how many heroes have you known, to be so certain of so dark a thing?" He demanded.
"Ohhhh many," she smiled. "Heroes of all shapes and calibres."
Just as the young guard gathered himself to fire another challenge, the music came to a flourishing stop, and the closing bell rang any words into oblivion.
Her audience rose, Suddenly eager to be away from her, muttering "it's not true"s and "mad old cow"s beneath their breath, yet not too low as to go unheard. But, as she obediently pulled her cloak back around her body, the soldier stormed towards her. She met his eyes calmly, and for a moment the anger in them wavered. She smiled as it returned. "Your training is going well?" She asked before he could find the sharp tip of his own tongue.
He cocked a bitter smile instead. "Very."
"Good."
Surprise collapsed his face as he realised she had moved at incredible speed for his sword, and he grasped for it in an attempt to keep it, but succeeded only in brushing its shadow. She was already turning it over in her hands.
"And how confident do you feel now?"
"Give it back," he barked, snatching for it, but she deftly wove it from his grip.
"Answer the question."
His eyes narrowed. "...Less..."
"As I thought." She gave it back. "Work to balance that confidence. The sword isn't the protector. You are."
He took it back quickly and returned it to its sheath. The movement wasn't as smooth as he had probably hoped, but she turned her attention to the door to spare him.
"Who are you?" He asked.
And she smiled easily. "Gladelyn the Reaper Moth."
He cocked a slender eyebrow. "Oh?"
"Don't believe me?" She smirked. "How about Eregelda Titanstone?"
"Ma'am, please--"
"Enterilngana of the Netherroads?"
He sighed and rolled his eyes. His anger was gone. 'Mad old woman' indeed.
She chuckled, then, and patted him firmly on the shoulder. "I apologise. Forgive an old woman her fun."
Then another bell chimed, this one further away, somewhere out in the western side of the city. The tavern's bell likely drowned out the first ring.
The soldier's face hardened at the sound of it, and his wearied eyes sharpened.
"Well," the old woman sighed, "it looks like you had better head back to the Tower. The monks will be out to hunt soon, and if they catch you--"
"They won't catch me. They'll be in smouldering pieces before I am."
"Hmm...it must be nice to be so young. Fare well, young master. May your wits be as sharp as your blade, but always in your hands."
He bowed, briefly, perhaps automatically, perhaps because of her age, or perhaps because a mad old woman was best respected if just to keep her calm, and as he turned and darted out of the door, she wandered for the staircase, took a lantern, and continued up to her quarters.
The room was small, leaving the shadows little space to dance, but it was enough. It was a temporary stop on her way to the east, and needed only house herself and two trunks.
She set the lantern on the single flat surface in the room, a small table near the bed as opposed to next to it, knelt down at the foot, and unlocked one of the trunks.
The hinges didn't squeak, she took far too good care of it for that, and she pulled her night clothes from the selection of cloth-wrapped bundles. They gave a slight clatter as they moved, a sound that, even though muffled, still managed to hurt her heart. There wasn't another quite like it to a trained ear, and nothing that could draw up so many memories and emotions from the past.
She reached out and rearranged what had slipped, pulling the cloth back over the glint of steel on the long and narrow bundle, and positioned it diagonally from corner to corner, the only way it would fit. The wide, flat oval too needed to be placed just so. And once they were back where they belonged, she closed the trunk tight and locked it again without a second's hesitation.
It was more than a little unpleasant to disrobe from her travelling clothes in the cold, but she longed to be rid of the way they clung to her and feel just vaguely more comfortable for the night, even if it were only a few hours. She had earned that much of a luxury, if nothing else.
And so she removed her cloak, untied her blouse, and peeled away the leggings, exposing her scarred skin only as long as necessary to the chill night air, before diving into the night clothes and the bed in one frantic movement. No sooner was she in it than she pulled the covers straight up to her chin. The bed, somehow, was colder than the air. Maybe she should have requested herself a sack of warm oats...
She sighed - her turn, now - rolled over and closed her eyes, waiting for the bed to warm up with her. But she knew it wouldn't be quick. In fact, she knew it would get colder first. She knew that, within a few minutes, the temperature would drop further, something in the air would change, and she would open her eyes and find herself staring into the ghostly face of her lover, lying in the bed beside her.
And like clockwork, within the passage of nine minutes, there he was. And he stayed, smiling softly, as her eyes filled with tears, until she finally wished him a good night and he vanished just as he did every other time.
She closed tear-brimmed eyes.
"And when a hero fails," she muttered to herself, "the cost feels so much higher..."
